Posted 2010-08-23 16:21:12
mike123ca, on 2010-08-23 14:27:24, said:
I've only taught public school in South Korea, It's been my experience if the School Admin likes you, then you will get renewed, but if they don't it's not difficult to find a replacement. The difficult part is that all year long they tell you that your a great teacher. Only near the end they will make you look bad to justify your departure. It's much harder to do the same if your one of the local teacher's. You can be a great teacher, but if they get bored with you, it's pretty hard to change things.
Sometimes you find a school you like, but I wouldn't take it too personally if they don't renew. I'll be soon teaching in Thailand, but I'll be on an O visa, I don't want to be at the mercy of the school. If I'm not renewed at a school, they won't be able to cancel my visa. I will apply at the school down the road on my own time.
Best of luck,
Mike
I know - that's the sad thing. I feel that I'm a good teacher and get on really well with my students, it's just a shame that teachers and politics get in the way. Unfortunately it doesn't help that the teacher that is making the decision has expressed his desire to only have young, handsome male teachers.
The other sad thing is that the other guy (the nice one) doesn't want to stay and even if he did he doesn't want to stay with the sh*t stirrer. He said the only reason that he lasted the 4 months of this semester is because of me.
I think my visa should be ok as I'm through an agency, plus they can move me to a new school unless I find something independently.
Street Cowboy - I tried talking to my teaching buddy about it today and asking if I have upset people. He says I haven't but then I wouldn't expect him to be honest with me. He was saying that it is his decision who stays a few weeks back but has suddenly deferred to another teacher because I don't think he wants to be seen as the bad guy.
Posted 2010-08-24 09:54:01
Hmmm, Sawatdeeeyes, I can't help echoing Boo's comments...run forest run!
You are teaching in a small small place it sounds like. The unfortunate thing about small small places is they often breed small small minds. Sad but true. Having grown up in a village in the UK, I have had a lot of experience of this, and again working in small town Thailand (though nowhere near as small and isolated as yours sounds). Whilst I was living in rural Thailand, the only REAL Thai friends I made were those who had actually moved from Bangkok. I was on friendly terms with a lot of Thai people in my town, including all my boyfriend's family, but I found our lives just too removed from each other to ever be able to make the real bond that I see as a true friendship. Don't get me wrong, I liked many people and had massive respect for the strength with which people (especially women) conducted their lives in often trying circumstances, but as for real rewarding give and take friendships?? Nah, nada.
This came down to a number of reasons. Firstly I felt I had to change who I was to be accepted (not smoke, not drink, not talk about my previous sex life etc). This was fine, but personally I cannot be real friends with someone if I am hiding a part of myself. Secondly I have found, from speaking to quite a few Thai girls, that Thai women have quite different attitudes to friendships than we do in the west. Thai girl friends are often extremely bitchy and competitive with each other, despite outside appearances, there seem to always be power struggles and the like going on amongst friends, like I remember from the playground, but these women are 30+!
Many of the women I met in my small town had never really been out of the town. They may have gone to Bangkok to study, but they often lived with other people from the same town, and lived very similar lives to the ones they did at home (with all news of their antics getting filtered back home). I am someone who really really needs good friends around me. I can deal with petty bitchiness and power struggles that you find in ALL Thai schools, as long as I have my friends that I can return to sanity with outside of school. Without having these around, I actually started to go a little crazy. Ultimately what made me leave my small town was the realisation that the relationships I made there were never going to go more than skin deep, because in actual fact, this is as far as many many relationships go here, even amongst Thais. Bearing in mind, I was experiencing all of this whilst still having my Thai boyfriend with me, who is actually very honest and westernized in his own relationships. That was still not enough to keep me there.
My opinion was why try and bash a square peg into a round hole. Enjoy the memories and experiences that your time has given you but please stop analysing what you have done or not done wrong. If these people really want to believe idle gossip that someone who has just arrived in spreading, I hate to say it, but they were never your friend in the first place. Move on, move out. I always say there is a huge difference between being culturally sensitive and actually losing who you are. You can have just as good time in Thailand, and have a much better support network around you by moving to a larger town. That's what I would recommend. You will probably look back on this period and realise that you perhaps weren't as happy as you thought you were.... and I know how it feels to miss the kids, but you will be surprised at how quickly you get attached to your new classes.
As a side note I am very very very surprised that your school admin's opinion is that they would prefer male teachers over female. I have worked in 4 Thai schools over my time here and at every one of them it has always been very obvious that they would prefer female farang teachers. These are often very hard to come by so in every case, I have been treated exceptionally well as the school was very eager to keep me on. The parents love seeing farang lady teachers, and schools are often very nervous of their teachers getting romantically involved with farang men due to the reputation it may give the school. I am very very surprised that the school is forcing you out. Are you positive there is no other reason behind this? Were you involved romantically with anyone? Sickness periods? I can't believe that they would force out a good teacher on the basis of gossip spread by a new teacher...they have already known you for a long while before this time to know whether what he is saying is true.
Posted 2010-08-24 16:15:44
Thanks Ms Sabai. I know, I need to get out of here. Like I've said, I just wish I could leave with people being friendly rather thant treating me as if I've got leprosy. My agency are coming to the school tomorrow to talk about contract renewals, so hopefully some light will be shed on the matter, but I won't count my chickens.
I think there are good and bad points living in both bigger towns and small villages. I agree, it was such a culture shock when I first came here that everyone knew my every movement. There is one other farang in the village (an older guy not attached at the school) who I'm very close to and I'm going to miss him a lot. I remember from the advice that I got when I first came to this forum warning me that it's VERY difficult to get genuine Thai friendships, so I haven't really invested much emotion in them but I do have a network of people that I enjoy spending time with and having fun with. I do have a good Thai friend who lives an hour away, she lived abroad for a few years so that's why she "understands" my farang ways.
I think I got used to the gossip but I have found the situation very oppresive at times not being able to do what I want to do or always thinking of my reputation. I think I've suffered the same as you in going a little crazy. I do drink in town, which was accepted but maybe the more they wanted to push me out the more that this has become a problem. Having had other farangs here has meant maybe I have been a little bit more Western than I was last semester.
As for other reasons... I've only had 1 sick day but I was quite depressed at the start of term, which hasn't been helped with the recent events.
I also think me "scolding" the teacher for repeatedly calling me the offensive name didn't help matters. I was advised to remember sabai sabai and jai yen yen but I don't think any culture would see what they said as funny. I can take the repeated comments on my weight but that was something else. I remember at the time him "joking" that "if you ever talk to me like that again you won't be here next semester." So I knew I was on shaky ground from that point, especially when he said that I had changed this semester, which was ound to happen because I had no other farangs to talk to last semester. I'm not very good at putting a face on things or brown nosing, so I probably did become detatched.
Throw into the mix that the other guy at school, who is absolutely adored, spends A LOT of time with me. So much so that my students now ask if he's my boyfriend and he's described as my "close" friend. I think that they possibly resent the amount of time he spends with me and probably think that I'm monopolising him (not the case, more the other way round).
As for wanting men over women... I know I was very shocked. My first semester all I got from my teaching buddy was "I wish you had been a man". He happens to be gay and the one who has been searching for the native English speakers, so that might be the reason why. When we were searching for someone for the s-stirrer's position he wanted someone under 30 and male. He disregarded A LOT of older applicants, who were actually native English speakers because he didn't like their photo. The head of English as well finds it very easy to relate to men but harder with women.
I'm just resorting to what Ian Forbes said and ignoring everyone. The funny thing is the only person that has not changed towards me is the guy that I originally posted about on this forum.
Posted 2010-08-25 12:45:18
Poor you, they sound like a pretty unpleasant bunch. My last school was great, but a school in the same town that I worked in was famous for it's bitchiness. The heads at the school seemed to encourage infighting - a kind of divide and conquer form of rule I guess. They would choose favourites and have spies, but these would often switch at the drop of a hat. Very dictatorial. My Thai friend who worked there said that they were even worse with the Thai staff. My guess is that if you are experiencing this, the Thai teachers are probably experiencing bitchiness all of their own.
Yeah I agree, balling people out was probably not the best course of action. But ultimately they were in the wrong, so for them to turn it back on you juts shows what petty bullies they are. I wouldn't bother yourself with the whys and whats of why things have turned sour. Chances are you will never get a straight answer and ultimately it doesn't matter. The school was not right for you...there will be plenty that are. As I said I have been lucky enough to work in four great schools in a row so your chances of finding a good one next time round are pretty high. I have always gone on personal recommendations for schools from people (mainly girls) who have already worked there. Give this a go if you do want to continue teaching here. Good luck! Grin and bear the next 4 weeks, or why not just completely go for it...get leathered every night, go down to the local waterfall in a bikini and nip off for fag breaks at school...if they want something to talk about, give it to them!
Posted 2010-08-26 15:57:38
[quote][quote]get leathered every night, go down to the local waterfall in a bikini and nip off for fag breaks at school...if they want something to talk about, give it to them Whichever way you want to look at it deep inside you know when it's time to look for new pasture and this experience will have toughened you right up. Good luck!
Posted 2011-05-09 00:05:28
Couple of comments to add...
First of all, I really wish I'd seen this thread last Aug. I was going through similar problems at my school. I also went back to work after the Khao Pensah holiday to find that the other teachers were blanking/refusing to talk to me, and that people in the town - who I'd always seen as nice and friendly - were behaving in the same way too.
Like you I struggled to try and work out what was going on, and why people had decided to pick on and gossip about me in the way they were doing.
Unlike you, I wasn't brave enough to say that I would stick my contract out. Unlike you, I resigned (I told the head of the school that I would leave one week after the gossip became worse... One day before this someone had unclipped the brake cables on my bike whilst it was parked at school and, from that moment on I was really worried about what people might do to my stuff/me if I stayed...
Even though I'd handed my notice in, the gossips did not stop. I asked the teaching agency that I worked for whether I could break my contract and leave early. They refused to acknowledge there were any problems at school. I insisted that they came to visit me at school to see the way that the teachers were behaving towards me for themselves. In the morning they saw (and said) that there were problems. They came back later that afternoon to say that the teachers had said that there was nothing wrong (even though they themselves had seen the way the teachers were treating me) and because of that I would have to stay until the end of my contract. Leaving early would have meant losing 2,000b a day in breach of contract fines.
One of my students (repeating what another teacher had said) slandered me in class, and I reported her to one of the Thai teachers. The Thai teacher interrogated her to the point where she was in tears denying that she had said anything. Eventually she said that she was only repeating what her mum - a nurse at the hospital - had told her. After that, whenever my student made rude remarks, I just ignored them. I didn't want to see the Thai teachers upsetting them again.
I was slandered and insulted until my contract ended in Mid Sept. Even then it didn't stop. I left quietly. My boss organised a small leaving ceremony and got some of my students to give me leaving presents. Some other teachers spread more gossip around town, about how selfish I was/how I had made the children cry/made the school waste loads of money as they had prepared a big leaving ceremony for me and spent a lot of time making a bai see (one of those big green folded banana leaf thingey-majigs you see in Thai ceremonies...) and I hadn't showed up...
This was not true, the school had done nothing - and the other foreign teachers at my school confirmed this - but the teachers there just wanted me to lose whatever little bit of face I still had left. The teachers also said that I was disrespecting Thai culture as they wanted to have a 'su kwan' (where people tie string around someones wrists) ceremony for me but I'd refused (there was no way that I could have listened to the same 2 faced, lying teachers who had made my life so hellish wishing me luck, good health etc...)
I also went back to the UK, took some time to think over what went on and wrong, and reached the same conclusions as some of the other post-ers here...
small town, small minds... thai women having nothing better to do that gossip... thai women being malicious/jealous/competetive... etc, etc...
Fast forward a couple of months...
I went back to the town in Nov to see a few friends. Back in the UK, being amongst family and friends, I figured that it would be OK to go back, (as at that time I had no idea what had been said about me or how serious the stories that were made up were....)
When I rode my bike past my old school, one of the teachers stopped me and said (in Thai...) 'so, the guy who came to school and said bad things about you.... is it OK now?' When I replied that I didn't know what she was taIking about she said 'forgotten already...thats good.' I was stunned. I'd no idea that it could have been connected to any guy.
Later on, I was told that this is what happened. A guy I used to know when I lived in BKK (and had formely thought of as a friend) had started dating a new gf, who 'didn't want you in the country.' 'wants you to live far away' They'd contacted people at my school and slandered me - as they wanted me fired. The school couldn't fire me on the spot (as I was employed by a teaching agency.... ) so my so called 'friends' there, decided to make my life as hellish as possible until I left.
I was told this very casually (like the person relaying the story expected me to know everything that happened, and to be totally unemotional about it.) When I heard I was in shock. I couldn't believe that no one told me what had happened....
The Thai girl had made me out to be a total psycho who would take revenge on the guys family if I found out that anything had been said. She claimed to be totally terrified of me. They also claimed - falsely - that I had deliberately visited the guys house, and that, since I knew where the guy's family lived, his family were worried that I would harm his family if I stayed in the area.
The guy's house is a good 150km from where my school was... it was somewhere i'd rode my bike past a lot - as its a shop on one of the main roads in the area, but not somewhere i'd ever 'deliberately' been to.. and all but one of the times I went there were before I had any idea whatsoever that it was his house (I knew him from BKK. I'd never seen him at home.) Plus the guy had previously told me that his house was in a town almost 10km away from the place I rode my bike...
Anyway, people in the town where I worked decided that I'd been to his house 3 times and deliberately tried to find him there. To add to this, the guy had made out that I was madly in love with him - definitely NOT true, we were never anything more than friends, and it was a pretty strange 'friendship' at that - and that when he'd said that he wasn't interested in me, I'd been to find him at his house.
In the midst of all the gossip at school, I used to joke with my Thai friends that my life was a real life 'lakorn nee ngow.' Going back to Thailand in Nov, it felt like it was becoming one for real.
Knowing what had happened made me question so much about my life there... Whether I really did have the friends/good relationships with my students that I thought I did.. whether I was that dumb as a person, that I couldn't see through the superficiality, whether I was going crazy (as when I tried telling someone that people were gossiping about me, they suggested that I was 'thinking too much' and going crazy...)
Like you I was told that 'I'd changed...' but nothing about me had changed. What had changed was the Thai teachers behaviour towards me, and as Thai's its far easier for them to blame their reactions on me eg. 'you've changed' than to accept responsibility for their own emotional immaturity and childishness.
Things that I knew were part of Thai culture (eg. no one questions a Thai person/older person... what they say is usually accepted as being true... no one will go against what a group of people say/will normally want to show they agree with it.... foreignerVthai - foreigner will almost always come off worse ) and had always accepted suddenly became very hard to accept.
I still can't believe that no one thought to question/check whether the stories that they told were true or not before people spread them around/reacted towards me in the way that people did... that no one from the school could/would tell me what happened... (did they really believe I was the crazy psycho person???? or were they just scared to stand out from the rest of the community???) I thought that, having lived in the town for over 2 years, I had a good relationship with my students/the other teachers/did a good job/was well liked/respected in the community but... THAT COUNTED FOR NOTHING!!!
One of my sister's bf's friend taught English in a village in Issan and suffered similar treatment to you (unlike you she wasn;t strong enough to stay and see it through to the end of her contract.) I remember telling the guy the story of how some people gossipped about her and made her life hell. I had no idea that, a few months later he and his new gf would do exactly the same thing to me...
Sorry just realised I've been waffling on for ages...
The other things I wasnted to say was that I really, really admire your strength for going back, and being able to do your job in that climate... and getting recognition for being a good teacher. If you can work with those women after the way they treated you, and bear no grudges towards them, then you are for sure...
Working in Thai schools (with all the politics/bitchiness) that goes on isn't easy.
Also, I really admire you for seeking advice and posting your story on here. I know of other people who have also had bad experiences in Thailand (dealing with gossip, politics at school etc...) and they all seem to think that its just them, and that its something that they have done/are doing wrong. Thai people also like to believe that they are really nice and friendly, treat guests well etc. and that if/when foreigners have problems living in Thai communities its the foreigners fault... Truth is, a lot of maliciousness and envy can be hidden behind those polite words and nice Thai smiles...
Posted 2011-06-06 11:45:19
does seem odd that after 9 months you had not cemented your relationships with the staff at the school already. as for the name thing well thats going to follow you every where and its no use have a go at people about it, mine translates to prostitute, 10 years i get sick of it but its not going to go away so learn to live with it. scolding a Thai guys not good for face etc a laugh and a smile would have been better.
hey thats my 1000 post up
Edited by NALAK, 2011-06-06 11:46:13.
Posted 2011-06-25 17:09:33
ok so here goes, I did a post a few months ago about having too much advice from the locals ............. lol latest update : I got myself evicted lmao
long story short , I had a baby in March , first 4 months I was here there was no problems at all . Then the BABY came............ the second I stepped out of the door would be comments, advice etc about the baby , non- freaking - stop , it drove me mad.
and they would draw conclusions based on what they see for 1 time, like I gave my baby cold milk ( pumped ) and they saw it , so they drew 2 conclusions a. she doesn't like to breastfeed 2. she only feeds her baby cold milk
they see him in disposable diapers ok a few times, conclusion , she's too lazy to cloth diaper her son, he going to be bow - legged!!!!
then I had chicken pox - yes as an adult so I had to get a neighbour babysit him, what does she do ????? gives him only cold milk , leaves a disposable diaper on him for like 6 hours !!!! And the best part , fed him water cos he didn't like the formula milk ....................well DUH he's been breastfed all the way , I told her 6 times to not give him water and she still did it !!!!
but what made me take him back after 2 days only was that she self medicated him !!!! After repeatedly telling her that he has a yeast infection on his neck, to NEVER let it get wet and what does she do ???????? yes, then she tries to fix the problem by applying baby oil on it !!!!! ( I also gave her the medicine for the yeast infection ) , took me a week to fix the problem after I took him bak.
After I took him back I ignored everybody , seldom took my baby out and if I did, covered him up so that no - one could see him until I got into a cab .
neighbour was landlady's daft sister, so I got evicted .......... good thing is that I found a great apartment at a better location and a REAL sitter nearby , FOR THE SAME RENT ................yay
advice for OP , move on, it's not worth it
OR like bina says start new gossip
Posted 2011-12-18 13:12:10
Senia, on 2011-06-25 17:09:33, said:
ok so here goes, I did a post a few months ago about having too much advice from the locals ............. lol latest update : I got myself evicted lmao
long story short , I had a baby in March , first 4 months I was here there was no problems at all . Then the BABY came............ the second I stepped out of the door would be comments, advice etc about the baby , non- freaking - stop , it drove me mad.
neighbour was landlady's daft sister, so I got evicted .......... good thing is that I found a great apartment at a better location and a REAL sitter nearby , FOR THE SAME RENT ................yay
advice for OP , move on, it's not worth it
OR like bina says start new gossip
Its so sad that these people have nothing better to do that gossip about or interfere with the lives of other people... and that Thailand has so many people/communities like this.
Im glad that moving out turned out to be better... A real babysitter who listens to what you say sounds much better than your old neighbour did...
I think one reason why a lot of people (girls who get bitched about at school etc...) are scared of moving on is that they think that things could be a lot worse somewhere else and dont want to take the risk of moving to a new town/village and having to deal with a new set of faces and the personalities behind the, all over again...
Another story / more stuff about moving on...
Last year one of my colleagues had a horrible time at school. The teachers loved and doted over her kids (dressing them up, putting make up on them, giving them candy etc...) but constantly bitched about her personality, her teaching, and the fact that the lights / computer / air con etc. in the teachers room were always left on. At one time, some of the Thai teachers used to stand on tiptoes peering through the window as they walked past the foreign teachers office to see whether anyone was sat in there (teachers absences - yep... no one seemed to accept the fact that the teachers were actually 'teaching', when they weren't in their office - and fag breaks were also bitched about too...)
The school offered to renew her contract... Other (Thai) people in town couldn't understand why she turned it down and was wanting to leave. She had what, to them was a good, well paid job, in a nice quiet town, the teachers loved and took good care of her kids etc... Thai people in local communities rarely see the way that Thai teachers behave towards their foreign staff. The Thai teachers create the impression that the foreign teachers are well liked (the truth is that whilst the students usually love foreign teachers... reasons vary from English being fun to foreign teachers not hitting students in class..., the Thai teachers are usually less admiring... and are often openly bitchy...)
Talking honestly (in this case negatively...) about how the Thai teachers really behave usually makes things worse... (as you destroy the little illusion that the teachers have created... that they are taking good care of their foreign guests etc...) It also leaves you open to attack (as you are being disrespectul to Thai culture. must be lying,... since no Thai person would ever behave/treat someone in the way that you have described etc...)
Anyway, I digress. Back to the story... She left... at first for a crappy job on the outskirts of BKK, and a few weeks for one of the jobs she really wanted, at an international school in the south. She's still there now... Is very well paid, has a much better job, nicer colleagues, a house near the beach etc....
Me... Jobwise, I haven't been so lucky... But since leaving that school in Sept 2010, and Thailand in Jan 2011 life has been an incredible adventure. Now a year and a bit later I can't help wondering why I wasted so much time and effort wondering why people were being so horrible to me... listening to and trying to analyse and find reasons for the maliciousness and all the lies and the gossip... It would have been far better to get well away from those people and that environment much sooner... though in my case escape would have been expensive. The agency I worked for said I must pay 2000b a day (almost double what I earnt each day) for breach of contract if I left my school before the end of term... The only things I got from staying until the end of term were insights into how nasty Thai people and the communities they are part of can be and serious test of my sanity, not things that I would recommend anyone experience...
To anyone else in a similar situation....
Move on... Look forward to making a fresh start, and the day when you'll be able to feel grateful for the experiences you had, but glad you don't have to listen to or deal with these people, and the situations they create ever again..
OP... Would be interested to know which agency you worked for...
Posted 2012-04-30 03:32:55
thread is very scary. is it this bad in the international schools?
Posted 2012-04-30 07:52:07
....dealing with bad situations in any environment by running away rather than confrontation, addressing the issues at hand and getting to the root/facts of the problem is defeatist at best.
... adopting a poor me attitude never got anybody anyplace .....
Looks like the OP has now got back on the rails by her own efforts...goodonya girl!
Posted 2012-04-30 09:20:23
farang000999, on 2012-04-30 03:32:55, said:
thread is very scary. is it this bad in the international schools?
No, it is a different story because the teaching staff and also the school directors are predominantly foreign.
Posted 17 minutes ago
To be frank welcome to thailand the land of childish people.Most of the time you will find this when you work with thais.They like back chat thats for sure..Find another country in asia mabye china or vietnam you will be a lot happier and treated better.Much love sorry to hear your story but belive me its not new.
|
Sponsored by ...
|